Jam Doughnut vs Cheddar
Last updated: 11 November 2026
Jam Doughnut and Cheddar both pay cashback when you buy a retailer’s gift card in their app, then spend the gift card at the shop. The cashback lands straight away, rather than weeks later. The main differences are in withdrawals and brands: Cheddar has a £5 minimum and says there’s no withdrawal fee; JamDoughnut needs £10 and charges a bank transfer fee, but lists more brands.
How gift-card cashback works
Instead of paying the shop directly, you buy a gift card for the amount you’re about to spend, and pay with that. Cheddar explains why the cashback can be instant: it earns a commission from gift card providers and shares it with you straight away, rather than waiting for the store to confirm your purchase. The catch is the extra step at every shop, and that the money sits on a gift card until you spend it.
How the Jam Doughnut app works
- You buy a digital gift card in the JamDoughnut app and get cashback points in your wallet straight away. It lists over 300 brands.
- 100 points are worth £1. Once you have 1,000 points (£10), you can take them to your bank account, for a bank transfer fee, or as gift cards.
- Cashback points expire 12 months after you last bought a gift card from JamDoughnut. Bonus points, such as for referrals, expire after 6 months.
- Gift cards can't be cancelled or refunded once bought, except under your statutory rights or if the card is faulty.
- It's free to join. You must be 18 or over, live in the UK and have a UK phone number.
How the Cheddar app works
- You pick a brand, enter how much you want to spend and pay using your bank. The cashback is added to your balance the moment you buy.
- You use the gift card like a debit card: scan it in-store or enter the code online. Some brands are in-store only, some online only, and the app shows which.
- You can redeem cashback to your bank at any time, with a £5 minimum. Cheddar says there are no subscriptions, transaction fees or withdrawal fees.
- Its terms say you need to use the app at least once every six months, for example by buying a gift card or withdrawing, to keep your cashback valid.
- It lists 100+ brands. You must be 16 or over with a UK bank account.
- Cheddar Payments Limited says it's authorised and regulated by the FCA. Its terms say its earlier automatic cashback closed to new rewards for purchases after 26 January 2025.
Jam Doughnut, Cheddar and earnr compared
| Jam Doughnut | Cheddar | earnr | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How you earn | Buy a gift card in the app, then spend it | Buy a gift card in the app, paying by bank, then spend it | Connect your bank once, then pay as normal |
| When cashback arrives | Straight away, as points | Straight away, to your balance | Pending while the retailer confirms, usually 30 to 90 days |
| Cost | Free to join | No fees | Free to use |
| Withdrawing | From £10, with a bank transfer fee, or as gift cards | From £5 to your bank, no fee | Coming soon, then from £5 to a UK bank account |
| Brands | Over 300 | 100+ | New and growing: see the live offers |
| Who can join | 18+, UK resident | 16+, UK bank account | 18+, UK resident |
Which suits you
- JamDoughnut: you want the most brands and you're happy to buy a gift card before you shop.
- Cheddar: you want a lower withdrawal minimum and no withdrawal fee, and the shops you use are on it.
- earnr: you'd rather not change how you pay. It's new, with fewer retailers, cashback is pending while the retailer confirms it, and withdrawals are coming soon.
Gift-card apps suit planned spending, like a weekly food shop, where you know the amount in advance. earnr works from the payments you already make, through read-only Open Banking. See how earnr works and how all the main cashback apps compare.
Questions
How does the Jam Doughnut app work?
You buy a digital gift card for a retailer in the JamDoughnut app and get cashback points in your wallet straight away. You then spend the gift card at the retailer. 100 points are worth £1, and once you have 1,000 points (£10) you can take them as a bank transfer, for a fee, or as gift cards.
Is Jam Doughnut legit?
JamDoughnut is run by JamDoughnut Limited, a company registered in England and Wales (number 12277192). It's free to join, and you must be 18 or over and live in the UK.
Does Jam Doughnut charge a fee?
It's free to join. JamDoughnut's terms say it charges a bank transfer fee when you take your cashback to your bank account. Taking it as gift cards is the other option.
Do Jam Doughnut points expire?
Yes. JamDoughnut's terms say cashback points expire 12 months after you last bought a gift card from it, and bonus points after 6 months.
Is the Cheddar app legit?
Cheddar Payments Limited says it is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (firm reference number 940075), and is registered in England and Wales (company number 12895809).
How do I withdraw from Cheddar?
Cheddar says you can redeem your cashback balance to your bank account at any time, with a £5 minimum and no withdrawal fee.
Is Jam Doughnut or Cheddar better?
It depends on where you shop and how you want to be paid. JamDoughnut lists more brands. Cheddar has a lower withdrawal minimum (£5 against £10) and says it charges no withdrawal fee. Check that the shops you use are on the app before you choose.
Is earnr a gift-card app?
No. earnr doesn't sell gift cards. You connect your bank once through read-only Open Banking, pay as normal, and purchases at retailers with a live offer are matched from your transactions.
Sources, checked 11 November 2026
- JamDoughnut: home page
- JamDoughnut: terms and conditions
- Cheddar: home page and FAQs
- Cheddar: terms and conditions
Other companies’ fees, rates and rules change. Check their own sites before you rely on them.
